3 Inventory Truths Your Square Dashboard Is Hiding From You

You love Square. I love Square.

It's beautiful. It's reliable. Customers trust the white reader. Your staff figured it out in ten minutes.

But here's the thing nobody talks about:

Square is a great register. It's a terrible CFO.

That dashboard gives you dopamine. Gross sales climbing. Transactions ticking. Little graphs going up and to the right.

But it's hiding the things that are quietly bleeding you dry.

---

Blindspot #1: The "Top Seller" Lie

Open your Square dashboard. Go to Items → Top Sellers.

You see a ranked list. The item with the most units sold sits at the top. You feel good about that item. You reorder it.

This is a trap.

Square ranks by quantity sold. That's a vanity metric. It tells you what moved — not what made you money.

Here's a real example:

Square says the tee is your winner. Your bank account says the blouse is your winner.

The tee created work. Returns. Refunds. Restocking. Customer service.

The blouse created profit. Clean sales. Happy customers. No drama.

Square shows volume. You need velocity adjusted for margin.

It doesn't show you that. So you keep reordering the wrong stuff.

---

Blindspot #2: The "Dusty Dollar" Problem

Square tells you how much inventory you have. It shows "Quantity on Hand."

What it doesn't show you: how long it's been sitting there.

That QOH number treats a dress that arrived yesterday the same as a dress that arrived six months ago.

They blend together. Old inventory hides in plain sight.

You walk past it every day. You don't see it anymore. It becomes furniture.

Here's the math that should terrify you:

If you don't see the age, you don't mark it down.

If you don't mark it down, it never leaves.

If it never leaves, that $800 never comes back to fund your next buy.

Square shows quantity. You need age. It doesn't give you age. So the dust collects.

---

Blindspot #3: The "Ghost" VIPs

Square saves your customer data. Names. Emails. Purchase history.

But it just saves it. It doesn't watch it.

Example: Sarah has spent $14,200 at your store over three years. She shops every 45 days like clockwork. She's a VIP.

Except she hasn't been in for 90 days.

Square doesn't tell you this.

No alert. No flag. No "hey, your best customer ghosted you." Nothing.

You find out six months later when she's fully switched to that new boutique across town. By then, it's too late.

Square stores your customer data. It doesn't work it.

Your VIPs are churning in silence, and your dashboard is showing you pie charts.

---

You Don't Need to Leave Square

Let me be clear: I'm not telling you to rip out your POS.

Square does what it does really well. Taking payments. Managing your catalog. Basic reporting.

But it was never designed to be your inventory strategist. Your cash flow analyst. Your customer retention system.

You need a brain on top of it.

Something that connects to your Square data and asks the questions Square won't:

Which items are actually profitable after returns?

What's been sitting here way too long?

Which VIPs are about to churn?

That's what I built RetailAdvisor to do.

One-click Square sync. No CSV exports. No manual uploads.

It reads your data and finds the blind spots — so you can fix them before they become expensive problems.

← Back to all posts